Marvel’s Wolverine Review: Does It Surpass Spider-Man? 

By Jack Shaw
illustration of Wolverine brandishing his claws

As an Amazon Associate, Modded gets commissions for purchases made through links in this post.


You would imagine that using the Marvel video game license would be a guarantee of success, and in a certain sense, it is, but just not the kind you’d expect. Insomniac Games captured lightning with Spider-Man, so anticipation for Logan’s adventure was sky-high. Could Insomniac replicate that magic with a darker hero, or does this PS5-exclusive Wolverine game carve its own bloody path?

  1. It Tells a Darker, More Personal Story

Insomniac delivers a cinematic experience that digs deep into Logan’s psyche, exploring themes of identity, trauma and redemption. The emotional weight hits hard, especially in quieter moments that stand in sharp contrast to the brutal action.

Marvel’s “Wolverine” has massive shoes to fill, considering “Spider-Man 2” proved the insane demand for these narratives by selling over 5 million copies in the first 11 days. The storytelling here rises to meet that standard while offering something distinctly different from Peter Parker’s more lighthearted adventures.

Liam McIntyre captures Logan perfectly — tough and intense, but with flashes of the guy just searching for some peace. The combat is less about flips and more about raw, tactical brawling. They pulled inspiration from military outfits and motorcycle body armor for his suit design, which adds an authentic feel. This attention to authenticity extends to how Logan moves, fights and interacts with his world.

  1. The Supporting Cast Raises the Emotional Stakes

The characters surrounding Logan elevate the drama considerably. Each brings unique challenges that test him physically and emotionally:

  • Jean Grey: Jean brings emotional weight and raw power to the story. Her connection with Logan gives the game room to explore trust, protection and the burden of fighting for people who cannot defend themselves.
  • Mystique: Raven Darkhölme adds intrigue as a skilled operative whose shifting identities make her one of the story’s more unpredictable figures. Her presence gives Team X more personality beyond pure muscle.
  • Sabretooth: Victor Creed is not just a simple villain here. As a Team X member with a complicated history with Logan, he brings rivalry, resentment and chemistry to the cast.
  • Omega Red: Omega Red gives the game one of its most physically dangerous threats. His connection to the Reavers and grudge against Logan make him a natural fit for the game’s nastier combat encounters.
  • Bolivar Trask: Trask appears to be the central threat driving the conflict. His anti-mutant agenda and use of the Reavers put Logan, Jean and Team X in a fight for mutant survival.
  1. The Combat Is More Brutal and Tactical

Once the adamantium claws come out, everything changes. Any Wolverine game review has to grapple with how the combat system embraces violence as a core mechanic, and Insomniac nails it.

The Core Combat Loop

Combat demands strategic thinking beneath the surface brutality. You can’t easily button-mash your way through encounters. The system requires careful attention to parrying, dodging and identifying openings in enemy defenses. This lethality fundamentally reshapes how combat flows compared to games featuring nonlethal heroes.

Healing and Rage 

The healing factor creates fascinating risk-reward scenarios. It handles chip damage automatically over time, but serious wounds require you to spend Rage to trigger manual healing bursts. Do you take a hit to charge your meter for a devastating special attack, or burn that Rage immediately to stay alive? These split-second decisions keep fights tense and engaging.

A Mature Edge

The game fully earns its Mature (M) rating without apology. Dismemberment, blood sprays and intense finishing moves are essential elements of portraying Wolverine’s reality. Boss battles amplify this intensity to remarkable levels, testing your skills while delivering spectacular violence.

The unapologetic M-rated gore is exactly why we might see the age verification checks recently enforced in the UK extend to other regions. This isn’t content for younger audiences, and the game doesn’t pretend otherwise.

  1. The World Favors Dense Hubs Over Open-World Freedom

The world design prioritizes density over sprawl, which serves the gameplay surprisingly well. Instead of a massive open map, the game features tightly crafted hubs packed with detail and purpose. Side activities feel meaningful rather than like a checklist scattered across an empty landscape. This design choice might disappoint players expecting Spider-Man’s sweeping cityscapes, but it better serves Wolverine’s core gameplay loop.

Unlike titles that offer intense combat and expansive exploration in equal measure, this game leans heavily into close-quarters encounters, regeneration mechanics and stealthy predator sections.

  1. The PS5 Performance Gives Wolverine Serious Bite
PlayStation 5 console and controller

Visually, the game showcases what the PS5 can accomplish. Character models display stunning detail, particularly the dynamic damage and regeneration visible on Wolverine’s body during fights. Near-instant loading between areas keeps momentum strong, while high-frame-rate combat stays buttery smooth even during chaotic encounters.

Environmental lighting and detail bring the dark, gritty world to life with remarkable fidelity. Exclusive powerhouses like this demonstrate exactly why the PS5 continues dominating the console market, selling 22.5 million units in 2023 alone.

The Verdict

Marvel’s Wolverine
https://unsplash.com/photos/yellow-blue-and-green-dragon-ball-z-character-orQhl6Is5Uw

The verdict in this Wolverine PS5 review is that the game stands proudly on its own terms. The story is genuinely mature and moving, with real emotional depth that explores Logan’s trauma and identity in ways most superhero games wouldn’t dare attempt. 

Liam McIntyre’s take on Logan captures both the savage berserker and the weary warrior seeking redemption. The combat stands out as some of the most brutal and satisfying in any superhero game, with the claw mechanics and healing factor creating a risk-reward loop that keeps every encounter tense. On top of that, the graphics really show off what the PS5 can do, from the incredible character detail to those near-instant load times.

However, the game isn’t without its rough edges. Traversal feels clunky and slow compared to other hero games built around mobility, which can make getting from point to point feel like a chore rather than part of the fun. 

The hub-based world structure may disappoint players expecting Spider-Man’s sweeping open-world freedom, as the tighter design trades exploration for focused encounters. Some side missions fall into repetitive patterns after extended play, particularly the combat-focused challenges that start to blend together in the late game.

Should You Play Marvel’s Wolverine?

The answer comes down to what you value in superhero games. It doesn’t surpass the Spider-Man game because it’s not trying to be it. This is a darker, more violent counterpart that stands as an equal rather than a successor. It’s a masterfully crafted character-driven action game that raises the bar for mature superhero stories.

You should absolutely play this if you love character-action games like “God of War,” appreciate the darker corners of Marvel comics or crave stories with genuine emotional weight. If you demand absolute freedom in sprawling open worlds, temper your expectations. For everyone else, the bloody path through this PS5 exclusive is well worth your time.

Jack-Shaw

Jack Shaw

Senior Writer

Jack is an avid outdoorsman with a taste for the finer things. An ideal day for him consists of lounging in a hammock and enjoying a nice glass of rosé.